Butterfinger, Small vs Andy's Banana Split

Compare calories, protein, carbs, fat, sodium, and fiber for these Andy's Frozen Custard menu items.

Quick answer

Butterfinger, Small is lowest in calories, while Andy's Banana Split gives the most protein.

Lowest calories

Butterfinger, Small

184 kcal

Highest protein

Andy's Banana Split

16 g protein

Lowest carbs

Butterfinger, Small

29 g carbs

Lowest sodium

Andy's Banana Split

19 mg sodium

Side-by-side nutrition facts

Values are per listed serving and may vary by location or preparation.

Menu item	Calories	Protein	Carbs	Fat	Fiber	Sodium
Butterfinger, SmallToppings	184 kcal	2 g	29 g	7 g	1 g	74 mg
Andy's Banana SplitSplits	563 kcal	16 g	113 g	22 g	13 g	19 mg

Choose Butterfinger, Small if your priority is keeping calories lower. It has 184 calories per serving.

Choose Andy's Banana Split if you want the most protein. It has 16g protein per serving.

If sodium matters, Andy's Banana Split is the lighter sodium pick at 19mg.

Open these items in the Andy's Frozen Custard calculator to see combined calories and macros.