NutrimetryRestaurant nutrition made simple.

☰

Last updated: Aug 9, 2026

Andy's Frozen Custard

Peanut Butter, Medium & Large

ToppingsPopular

Andy's Frozen Custard Peanut Butter, Medium & Large is fat-leaning, with about 72% of macro calories from fat. Each serving has 428 calories, 18g protein, 14g carbs, and 36g fat, making it worth balancing with lower-fat items in the same meal.

1 Serving

Serving Size

Add to Meal Ask AI about this item

428

Calories

Per serving

18 g

Protein

14 g

Carbs

36 g

Fat

Nutrition Facts

Amount per serving

Calories428 kcal

% Daily Value*

Total Fat 36 g46%

Saturated Fat 6 g30%

Trans Fat 0 g—

Cholesterol 0 mg0%

Sodium 315 mg14%

Total Carbohydrate 14 g5%

Dietary Fiber 7 g25%

Total Sugars 7 g—

Protein 18 g36%

Vitamin A—

Vitamin C—

Vitamin D—

Calcium—

Iron—

Potassium—

Caffeine—

* The % Daily Value tells you how much a nutrient in a serving contributes to a daily diet.

Nutrition Breakdown

428

kcal

Protein18 g (16%)

Carbs14 g (12%)

Fat36 g (72%)

Estimated calorie contribution using 4 kcal/g for protein and carbohydrates and 9 kcal/g for fat.

Meal Planning Insights

Protein density4.2/10

16% of macro calories come from protein.

Satiety index10/10

Estimated from protein, fiber, calories, and fat balance.

Activity estimate107 min walk

About 43 minutes of running for these calories.

Key Nutrients

Protein 18 g36%

Fiber 7 g25%

Sodium 315 mg14%

Sugars 7 g—

Saturated Fat 6 g30%

How we calculate these values

Diet Compatibility

High protein4.2/10 protein density from 18g protein and 428 calories.No

Lower carb14g carbs per serving.Yes

Low fat36g total fat per serving.No

High sugar7g total sugars per serving.No

High sodium315mg sodium per serving.No

Vegetarian source flagNo vegetarian flag is published for this item.Not flagged

Similar Items in Toppings

View all

Almonds172 kcal · 6 g protein

Compare with other items

Select up to 3 items to compare calories, protein, sodium, and macros.

Quick comparisons

Peanut Butter, Medium & Large has 256 more calories than Almonds and 12g more protein. Compare

Peanut Butter, Medium & Large has 135 fewer calories than Andy's Banana Split and 2g more protein. Compare

Almonds172 kcal · 6 g proteinAndy's Banana Split563 kcal · 16 g proteinAndy's Chocolate Custom Concrete, Large1,113 kcal · 26 g proteinAndy's Chocolate Custom Concrete, Medium769 kcal · 18 g proteinAndy's Chocolate Custom Concrete, Small557 kcal · 13 g proteinAndy's Chocolate Custom Sundae, Large610 kcal · 14 g protein

Compare with Almonds

Peanut Butter, Medium & Large Compared With Nearby Items

Compared with Almonds, another Toppings item at Andy's Frozen Custard, Peanut Butter, Medium & Large has 256 more calories than it and 12g more protein than it. That makes this page useful for deciding between nearby menu choices, not just reading a raw nutrition label.

Data Source and Methodology

Nutrition values for Peanut Butter, Medium & Large are maintained in Nutrimetry from restaurant-published menu data and were last checked on Aug 9, 2026. Macro percentages use 4 calories per gram for protein and carbohydrates and 9 calories per gram for fat.

Read the data methodology

Ask AI about this item

Get personalized nutrition advice and meal ideas.

Is this good for muscle gain?Can I eat this while cutting?

Ask AIAsk Nutrimetry AI